The holidays are supposed to be about comfort. Twinkly lights. Familiar rituals. The reassuring knowledge that everything will be fine by dessert. Which, frankly, is why a well-placed murder works so well this time of year. Nothing cuts through forced cheer like a body where the poinsettias should be.
If you like your seasonal stories with sharp dialogue, clever plotting and narrators who understand that festive does not mean flimsy, these audiobooks are ready to keep you company while you wrap gifts, dodge relatives, or pretend to clean. Cozy-adjacent, clever throughout, and deeply listenable — consider this your holiday alibi.
Mistletoe Murders 4 by Ken Cuperus
Emily Lane is back — and Fletcher’s Grove hasn’t magically become safer in her absence. In the long-awaited fourth installment of the Mistletoe Murders series, Cobie Smulders once again brings warmth, wit and quiet steel to the role of a Christmas-store owner who keeps tripping over homicide.
This season leans into emotional history as much as mystery. Emily returns after a long break to a town full of unfinished business: an ex she hasn’t resolved, his new girlfriend she didn’t expect and a past that refuses to stay buried. When someone else from her history shows up under suspicious circumstances, the question isn’t if this is connected — it’s how far back the game goes.
The result is a tightly produced, character-forward listen that balances holiday atmosphere with real stakes. It’s no surprise this series inspired a Hallmark hit!
Murder at Mistletoe Manor by Holly Tierney-Bedord
Seven guests. One December night. A bed-and-breakfast that suddenly becomes far too busy for comfort.
Klarinda Snow prides herself on offering guests peace, quiet and mountain charm — not mystery injuries and escalating suspicion. When accidents begin piling up at Mistletoe Manor, it becomes clear that this isn’t a run of bad luck, but something far more deliberate.
This novella wastes no time setting the mood or raising the tension. The setting is intimate, the cast is nicely contained,and the pacing keeps the mystery moving without overstaying its welcome. Ideal for listeners who want a quick, satisfying holiday whodunit that still delivers a solid punch.
Manhattans and Murder by Jessica Fletcher & Donald Bain
Jessica Fletcher in New York at Christmas is exactly as fun as it sounds … and slightly more dangerous.
In town to promote her books, Jessica expects a packed schedule of signings and interviews. What she doesn’t expect is a sidewalk Santa who recognizes her and looks terrified. From there, the mystery unfolds with the polished ease fans of the series expect, blending city sparkle with an old-fashioned investigative backbone.
Beth Porter’s narration captures Jessica’s intelligence and warmth beautifully, making this a comforting yet clever holiday listen that proves some mysteries age like a well-made Manhattan.
The Mystery of Mistletoe Hall by Benedict Brown
A snowbound manor. A missing host. Eight strangers who should not all be in the same place — and absolutely shouldn’t trust one another.
Set in 1925 England, this standalone mystery drops Lord Edgington into a holiday gathering that rapidly becomes a closed-circle nightmare. As the snow deepens and the body count rises, every guest reveals a role to play in a game none of them signed up for.
This is classic-style mystery done with confidence and charm: clever misdirection, sharp character work and just enough humor to keep things from going grim. George Blagden’s narration adds gravitas and warmth in equal measure, making this an especially satisfying listen for fans of traditional whodunits with a modern sense of momentum.
Jane and the Twelve Days of Christmas by Stephanie Barron
Christmas at a grand country estate should be idyllic, unless you’re Jane Austen, in which case it’s also an excellent opportunity to uncover murder.
Set in 1814, this installment places Jane among friends, family and carefully observed social rituals. When one guest dies under suspicious circumstances, Jane’s keen eye for human behavior becomes the most valuable tool in the room.
The mystery unfolds through parlor games, charades and whispered secrets, creating a layered, intelligent puzzle that rewards attention.
Death with All the Trimmings by Lucy Burdette
Christmas in Key West comes with boat parades, visiting relatives, and — unfortunately — arson and murder.
Food critic Hayley Snow is pulled into a dangerous investigation when a chef’s restaurant is sabotaged, then destroyed, with lethal consequences. Between holiday obligations and rising danger, Hayley must untangle culinary rivalries, personal grudges and a killer who isn’t done yet.
This installment blends food writing, holiday chaos and high-stakes mystery into a lively, sun-soaked listen that proves festive murder doesn’t require cold weather.
